Financial Analysis of Proposals - 1780 Words

MEMO To: CEO, ECGM Ltd. From: External Consultant, Awesome Consulting Corp, LLC. May 14, 2012 Re: Financial Analysis of Proposals. Executive Summary The two proposals that were sent to the office of External Consultant on May 11, 2012 were subject to financial analysis using a number of different techniques. It has been determined that neither of these projects should be undertaken by ECGM Ltd. Both projects presented will, if undertaken, erode shareholder value. The details that lead to this conclusion, including the different assumptions and analysis using the methodology that ECGM provided are presented in this memo. Signed, External Consultant. i) The payback method of capital budgeting is the time period where the cash inflows from the project pay back the initial cash outlay. The formula for payback period, when the cash flows are stable is: Cost of Project = _________________ Annual Cash Inflows Source: Investopedia (2012) Using the payback method, Proposal A has a payback period of 6 years and 3 months, as calculated using the formula: 20,000 / 3200 = 6.25 years The payback formula cannot be used with Proposal B because that project has no stable annual cash flows. The dumb way of calculating payback must be used, simply adding the figures until it becomes positive, and then figuring out where the point where the projects cash inflows have equaled its outflows is. Proposal B has a payback period of five years and 262 days. Proposal B has theShow MoreRelatedPerforming A Cost Benefit Analysis1635 Words   |  7 Pages(A). Performing a cost-benefit analysis would help the project manager and team compare and establish vendor financial and non-financially benefits. By performing a cost-benefit analysis, the project manager can gain benefits by selecting vendors and suppliers that specialize in certain areas. Performing the cost-benefit analysis would highlight vendor strengths in delivery, flexibility, quality and reliability, fair price, familiarity, and financial and business stability that would best meet theRead MoreVendor Selection Process Redesign Proposal For Procurement1046 Words   |  5 Pagesredesign proposal for procurement The purpose of this proposal is to improve or change the vendor selection process to purchase of goods and services from Third Party Company for production of company products. In the company, the vendor selection process is managed by a project manager with the help of purchasing department. This includes the following process: †¢ Identification of potential vendors †¢ Request for proposal †¢ Evaluate response. †¢ Select vendor after negotiation. But in this proposal, theRead MoreEvaluation Of A Memorial Hospital1622 Words   |  7 Pagesmembers from their financial and planning offices to develop a strategic approach to expand their surgical capacity and to improve patient satisfaction. The draft proposal calls for a two-phase capital project intended to increase operating room capacity, address technology limitations, and improve patient satisfaction. The proposal has many key pieces of information pertaining to the successful completion of the project. It delivers a clear analysis of financial growth, analysis of both inpatientRead MorePad 505 Assignment 3 Presenting the Budget1154 Words   |  5 PagesPrepare the financial plan and budget justification proposal. The agency is contracted to work with New York City on several capital projects. To proceed with negotiations, an analysis of the city’s financial documents must be considered. Review the New York City Financial Plan, located athttp://www.nyc.gov/html/omb/downloads/pdf/fp6_12.pdf,to answer questions listed. (Title this section â€Å"New York City Financial Plan†) 1. Answer Question 1 based on the review of the New York City Financial Plan: AreRead MoreThe Role Of Vehicle Over Taker By Shibu Babu1462 Words   |  6 PagesThe presentation that I will be evaluating is ‘Vehicle Over-Taker’ by Shibu Babu. My role as an investor is to assess the overall business proposal/concept by using a structured, methodical approach to analyse financial and non-financial information, forecast the impact of these factors and take investment decisions on these grounds. The business proposal, ‘Vehicle Over-taker’, is in relation to the invention of an electronic device that can prevent overtaking accidents caused by the dynamic drivingRead MoreCompany Analysis : Enager Industries, Inc.772 Words   |  4 PagesProducts Division. McNeil’s product proposal was estimated to generate $390,000 in pretax earnings (EBIT) and contribute a $0.15 increase in earnings per share (EPS). In an effort to earn a gross return of 12%, Hubbard, Enager’s CFO, decided approval of new investments required a target return of at least 15%. Consequently, Hubbard rejected McNeil’s proposal because ROA falls short at 13%. In my opinion, McNeil’s proposal should not have been rejected. Although the proposal fails to meet the 15% targetRead MoreNew Heritage Doll Company Write Up1317 Words   |  6 PagesCompany, Emily Harris, is to forward her project proposal to the Budgeting Committee for evaluation. The Vice-president’s objective for proposing the project was based on potential to strengthen the Company’s division of production and drive future growth. Emily Harris has to produce a compelling project to avoid the committee from declining the proposal. Basis of Assessment There are two projects between which the company can choose from or drop the proposals in their entirety. The methods of project evaluationRead MoreThe Importance Of Ring Fencing And Loss Absorbency1420 Words   |  6 Pagesthe banking system. This paper will be focusing on the proposals for ring-fencing and loss absorbency, explaining what these proposals are about and how can they make changes to the banking system. Then by comparing the differences of ring-fencing from other structural reform, and realizing the effect of the loss-absorbency on the banking system, analysis from different views will be made for drawing up a conclusion on whether these proposals can successfully achieve the ultimate goal, which is creatingRead MoreMarketing Pl An Organization1658 Words   |  7 Pagesroadmap to follow, cover-your-bases, construct necessary support systems, protect yourself and dramatically improve your chances for marketing success. Critical elements of a Marketing Plan Target M arketing – establishing target customers, Competition Analysis, SWOT (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats), SMART Goals, Strategies and Tactics, Marketing Budgets, and Marketing System.† (Gandolf, 2010). **The Executive Summary, a concise summary of the planning issue, a future-oriented documentRead MoreTools Used in Financial Management625 Words   |  3 PagesThere are wide range of tools used in such as, cost of capital, financial leverage, capital budgeting appraisal methods, ABC analysis, ratio analysis and cash flow statements. (a) Cost of capital Cost of capital is an important element in investment decision or basically in business. It is used to measure the value of investment proposal provided by investment concern. It is used as discount rate in defining the present value of future cash flow which is associated with capital projects. Cost